The way you got those faces on the fruits is just FLAWLESS! It looks like they were born that way! LOL! TOO FUNNY! Great image!

I remember this from the old site. Great stuff Ethan!!

Composition:
This looks fine to me. The angle really gives a flair to the composition.
Creativity:
This is without a doubt, creative. Very important to keep from being cliche when photoshopping. The easy route is often taken. Putting someone's head on another's body for example. I think you are well clear of that here though.
Subject:
A creative and whimsical subject here.
Technical:
Technically sound. The blending is well done, you obviously took the face shots to match the angle and direction of the fruits. The white board background seems too dark at the edge though. I would expect that you haven't been able to invest in good studio lighting yet. But the subject lighting is above average.
Image Quality:
Image quality is great, so many good artists ignore the actual quality of the image that is displayed. I might want to sharpen up the apple if it were mine, however, most may not notice it.

very creepy, but very cool!!